In the first part of converting my Sudoku solver React app from using Flux to Redux I looked at creating the Redux Store, Action Creators, reducers, and connecting Components to the Store. In this part 2 I’m taking a look at using redux-thunk for making my api calls.
Async API calls are integrated into a Redux app by using a ‘thunk’, support is provided by adding react-thunk to your app:
npm install --save redux-thunk
react-thunk is a middleware for your Redux Store. It looks at each Action dispatched to your Store and if it’s a function instead of an Action object it executes it.
Where you create your store with createStore(), add an import for applyMiddleware and thunk:
import { applyMiddleware, createStore } from 'redux';
import thunk from 'redux-thunk';
const middlewares = [thunk];
Pass a call to applyMiddleware as a param to createStore() passing this middlewares array. In my app I’ve already passed the devToolsEnhancer() to createStore():
let store = createStore(puzzleDataReducer, devToolsEnhancer());
Naively, I thought I’d be able to add thunk and devToolsEnhancer() in the array and pass like this:
const middlewares = [thunk, devToolsMiddleware()];
let store = createStore(puzzleDataReducer, applyMiddleware(...middlewares));
… but this leads to some rather cryptic errors and I’ve honestly no idea what this means or how to resolve it:
VM1047:1 Uncaught TypeError: t.apply is not a function at :1:47480 at :1:33759 at :1:26192 at eval (redux.js:602) at eval (redux.js:646) at createStore (redux.js:79)
Luckily a quick search found this article, suggesting the way to combine these enhancers is to use redux’s compose() function. Import compose from redux:
import { createStore, applyMiddleware, compose } from 'redux';
Use compose() to combine thunk and the devToolsEnhancer() call like this:
compose( applyMiddleware(thunk, otherMiddleware()), window.devToolsExtension ? window.devToolsExtension() : f => f )
In my case I don’t have other middleware to include, so my createStore() was originally this:
let store = createStore(puzzleDataReducer, devToolsEnhancer());
and now including thunk and using compose() it looks like this:
let store = createStore(puzzleDataReducer, compose( applyMiddleware(thunk), window.devToolsExtension ? window.devToolsExtension() : f => f ) );
Next I need to move my Flux Action that makes my api call to a function that is returned by an Action Creator. Since react-thunk looks for functions returned by Action Creators instead of Action objects and executes them. this was a relatively minor change moving the function from my original Action to my Action Creator.
At this point I’ve got a working app, migrated from Flux to Redux. You can check the final result on GitHub here. I’ve still got some cleanup to do – in particular I don’t have a clean separation between my reducer code and my Action Creator code. I’ll code back and do some cleanup later, and also deploy a parallel copy of the same app to AWS. Right now the original Flux based app is deployed here. I’ll deploy the final Redux based app shortly.
One Reply to “Updating my React Sudoku Solver app: Replacing Flux with Redux (part 2)”